May 27, 2012

The Marriage Project, Reflection 53: “I also believe in commitment without paper work, but the paper work does have some perks.”

M: “I am a 34 year old woman,  fiercely independent, an Executive Pastry Chef for a high end hotel,  a very male dominated profession. I bought my home alone, never needed a man to get by.  I am a relation-shipper. I have long term relationships but have never really pushed for marriage mainly because of the belief that a man should not be pressured to be with you.  He should want the commitment as much as you do, if not more.  I also believe in commitment without paper work, but the paper work does have some perks.  For a long time I could take marriage it or leave it.”

Why am I choosing to get married?

I love him.  S and I have been together for 6 years.  We are well past the getting to now you phase of the relationship, the honeymoon stage of candy, roses, and everyday sex is long gone.  I am feeling my biological clock ticking and I would like to be attached legally to the man  that I am going to have children with. Plus, if I died,  he would have no rights to the home we share or anything I would leave behind, and vice versa.

Wedding planning?

I want a marriage,  not a wedding after signing a prenup.  I could elope tomorrow. S wants “the traditional day” with family and friends.  I am OK with a very small event.  The wedding is a year away and already I am being pressured to inviting family I have not talked to in years, getting a band, and I am waiting for the “Catholic” guilt because we are not having a religious ceremony (Who would I be kidding? I am far from a virgin and we are not church people).  I am ready to go to Vegas.  None of this is remarkable or surprising, it was expected.  Plus, the costs are crazy, also expected.  At least I can make my own cake.

The word wife?

I joke that S is the wife.   I do not subscribe to the traditional Susie homemaker image.  We have our own roles in the relationship. I cook, he cleans, I am the handyman and we both work.  The word fiance trips me up more, it just does not role off my tongue well.

What do I expect marriage to be like?

More of the same.  It will not effect our roles.  We have been together longer than most marriages last.

My name?

This has been a point of anxiety for me.  In a way I want to take the traditional route of changing it.  S would be happy and I would feel more like a family if we have kids. I also feel like I will be losing a part of my identity if I changed it. I love my last name.  To be determined.

The role of the wedding?

Besides being a stress filled event? I never had the fairytale wedding fantasy. I like the the image of saying  vows to each other, it’s romantic.  

May 24, 2012

The Marriage Project, Reflection 52: “I believed it would last. But we all know it takes two people to do this.”

E is a relationship coach and advice columnist living in Ohio

Why did you decide to get married?

Honestly, the main reason I decided to get married to my ex-husband is because I found out I was pregnant. Of course, I wanted it to last. I believed it would last. But, we all know it takes two people to do this.

What changes have divorce/separation brought to your life?

The question should be, “What changes hasn’t divorce brought to your life?”  It may be hard to understand, but I wouldn’t change anything that has happened to me, divorce included. It has helped me become the strong, dedicated, and brave woman that I am. I also have a wonderful son because of it.

How has divorce/separation changed your view of marriage?

The only thing that has changed with my view of marriage is that couples really must spend more time together before they decide to do it. I only knew my ex for 5 months tops before we married. People really need to slow down and not rush things. Get to know each other and live together even longer. My fiance and I have been together now for 4 years, engaged for 2. No rush…

Do you think you’ll get married again? Why? Why not?

Absolutely. I still believe in marriage and everything it stands for between two people who truly love each other and decide to make such a strong commitment. Right after my divorce I didn’t feel I could ever marry again (as I think most people do), but that was well over 8 years ago. We live and learn and hopefully become better people and find ourselves along the way.

What advice would you give to women who are going through divorce/separation?

Divorce is not the end of the world. You may be thinking it’s the end of your life as you know it. And, maybe it is… However, you have a choice to make your new life as rich as you want it to be. If you are going through a divorce or separation the best thing to do is dive into something you have always wanted to do for you. Whether it’s a hobby, going back to school, begin a work out regimen , or even something as simple as a makeover. This is your time to anything you have ever wanted without someone holding you back!

May 17, 2012

wednesday (photos by me)

IMG_0119

IMG_0120

IMG_0123

IMG_0130

May 16, 2012

“but when the wind is in your hair you laugh like a little girl.”

IMG_0091

(somewhere off flatbush avenue,brooklyn. photo by me.)

songs for tuesday evening/wednesday morning: stay young, go dancing, death cab for cutie; september, the shins; an innocent fiction, erin mckeown; night of the living dead, tilly and the wall; you and me and the moon, the magnetic fields.

It’s almost 12.30 am at the Starbucks on Astor Place. I adore this city for its insomniacs and night owls and nonsensicals and the places that stay open to enable it all. I was walking on the Lower East Side, carrying a pile of labor anthologies and listening to the Magnetic Fields, and I couldn’t seem to make myself turn towards the subway and go home.  I  can’t afford to ignore the monsters when they start feeling real enough again to write. It’s like a fucking rabbit hole sometimes, but you have to go down. (And by you, I mean me.)

May 14, 2012

The Marriage Project, Reflection 51: “I do not regret my marriage because getting divorced was the best thing to happen in my life.”

(published in 1937)

R is 32 and lives in Maine.

Why did you get married?

I was never one of those girls, or teenagers, or women who dreamed about her wedding day. It never occurred to me to fantasize about that event. I daydreamed about life with a partner, and had considered what it would be like to be a co-parent, but the actual marriage ceremony was not something that excited me. Honestly, I think I got married because he asked, and I didn’t see a reason to say no. Our relationship had become pretty rocky 3 months in, and had remained so when we got married 3 years later. He consistently and very rationally explained to me that relationships were hard work, and that I had to work on myself and my behaviors in order to better our relationship. I took on a lot more responsibility than was my fair share for the problems in our relationship, and when I rarely attempted to hold him accountable for his contributions, I experienced such a backlash that I would feel guilty and ultimately regret it. So I drank the Kool-Aid and lived my life as the good girlfriend, and then the good wife, asking my therapist to hold me accountable for our relationship problems, consoling my man when two separate couples therapists told him he was blaming too much on me and not taking enough responsibility for his role in our troubled paradise. I thought it was normal to have that many knock-em-down drag-em-out fights. I thought every couple had those kinds of issues. I thought so because he told me so, and since I was rather inexperienced in the relationship realm, and he was 5 years older than me and very smart, I believed him. So when he asked me to marry him, I said yes. It was fun and exciting, and even though our problems continued through our engagement, marriage seemed like the reasonable next step.

What changes have divorce/separation brought to your life?

I am exponentially happier, and everyone can tell. My parents were in udder shock and denial when they found out (from him, no less) that I was getting divorced. They kept saying that maybe our separation would bring us closer together. Not even a month after my divorce was finalized, my father sent me an article titled “When Divorce IS Happily Ever After.” He noticed almost immediately how much lighter and more joyful I was. I also stopped lying to my parents about my relationship struggles, and I stopped hiding my emotional ups and downs from my siblings. I smoke less pot and drink more whiskey. I no longer apologize for things for which I am not sorry or not accountable. I learned how to make really tough choices about my finances, my relationships, and my career by listening to my heart and soul, with advice from loved ones, but without having my answers dictated to me by a partner. I dance more often with complete abandon. I am open to receiving more support from my friends. I choose my friends independently, growing closer to some and more distant from others of our mutual friends. I focus my therapeutic and healing practices on my personal growth and not on saving a relationship. I learned how to stand up for myself and stop taking other people’s bullshit. I learned how to fight with someone, still love them, and then laugh about it later that same day. I have exponentially better sex. I treat myself better and love myself more. Without someone nagging me to go to sleep earlier and eat better, and without someone to nag to relax, let loose, and go with the flow, I play all of those roles for myself, and feel more supported and more free than ever before. I feel more at home in my own body and soul. I found my strong, powerful, beautiful, amazing self, and I’m enjoying getting to know her better every day.

How has divorce/separation changed your view of marriage?

Marriage doesn’t seem sacred anymore. Maybe it never did. Through all our struggles leading up to our wedding day, I think I knew in the back of my mind that if it really didn’t work out, I could always get divorced. If I were living in another country, where divorces are much less common and much harder to secure, especially for a woman, I might not have gotten married in the first place. In the USA, if you’re heterosexual, getting married and getting divorced are not very difficult processes (especially if you’re lucky like me, with no children and no shared property). A real, true, loving partnership, now that’s harder to come by, and I don’t need a glorified tax break to commit to and treasure that kind of relationship.

Do you think you’ll get married again? Why? Why not?

I don’t know. I am not opposed to getting married again, but I do not feel any kind of pressure, or even strong desire, to do so. Three years after my divorce, I finally feel ready to get into a committed relationship again. That would be nice. If that relationship becomes serious and long term, I might be interested in some sort of commitment ceremony or celebration, to honor our relationship in the presence of friends and family. But marriage itself has lost its sparkle for me. With so many states legally defining marriage as a union between a man and a woman, getting married is starting to feel more like a political move, and I’m not interested in being a greedy heterosexual. I guess if I was in a really strong, healthy, loving relationship, and I was sure (as sure as one can be) that I wanted to be with that person for the rest of my life, and that person really wanted to be married to me… I would consider it.

What advice would you give to women who are going through divorce/separation?

Do not look at your divorce as a failed marriage. Look at it as a next step in your development as a human being. Easier said then done, I know, but I do not regret my marriage because getting divorced was the best thing to happen in my life. I am so much stronger, happier, and healthier for it, and I couldn’t have gotten there without having gone through the whole process. Talk about it. You’ll be surprised how many people you know have been divorced—your coworkers, your hairdresser, your yoga instructor, even your own family members. I somewhat shamefully sent messages to my extended family, telling them the news and my new address. I was shocked at the amount of support I received in return. Somehow I had forgotten that my cousins were on their second marriage (the first one is for practice, they said), and that my Nana had been divorced twice, widowed once, and married four times. Perhaps I am blessed with a very supportive family, but the shame I initially felt melted away with an outpouring of support and love from my extended family. Therapy also helped. A lot. Which reminds me… Go to therapy. You will learn so much about yourself, and you don’t have to worry about wearing out therapists’ ears, because they’re professional listeners. Just do it. Find kinship with other women who have gotten or are getting divorced. You will help each other keep in line and not go too far off the deep end. You will move each other out of your married residences and into new single abodes. You will attend each other’s divorce hearings and provide emotional support. You may even drag each other, drunk and sobbing, upstairs, through the kitchen, and into the bedroom, barely able to crawl let alone walk, crying for your losses and holding on to one another for dear life. And then you may grow apart as you grow stronger standing on your own. Maintain your social life and your regular support networks. Don’t NOT go somewhere only because you think your ex will be there. You are just as much entitled to a social life as your ex is. Keep in touch with your mutual friends. They’re your friends too. They might not reach out to you right away, because they might be embarrassed or not know quite how to handle the situation, and they might be grieving your relationship themselves. But most likely, they still love you and want to be your friends. I actually noticed that my friendships got stronger after my divorce. Because I couldn’t rely on my partner to make social plans for me, it was up to me to maintain those relationships, and when I invested more in my friends, they invested more in me. Keep up with whatever activities you normally do to feel whole in your life, especially the healthy ones, like exercise and creative expression. With the unhealthy ones, just be gentle with yourself. It might be better to quit smoking or lose 10 pounds after some post-divorce healing time has passed. Meanwhile, treat yourself to a pedicure. Above all, do not judge yourself. I did crazy, unhealthy, and abnormal things while I was getting divorced. I slept around, sometimes having great sex with great men, and sometimes having awful sex with disgusting men, just to be having sex. For a few weeks, I stayed with a friend who was also going through a divorce, and we drank like fish every night, almost getting kicked out of bars, flirting with every man we saw, and starting and ending affairs with both single and married men. I started smoking cigarettes. I got my first two tattoos in the same month (but I do not regret either one!). I overworked, hardly slept, and overdosed on processed foods mostly consisting of white flour and fake cheese. Perhaps these behaviors are normal for some people, but they were abnormal for me, and I recognized how unhealthy some of them were even as I was engaging in them. Some I still engage in, and some I don’t regret at all. And my divorce was a huge relief! For women like my aforementioned friend, who are extremely saddened and distraught by their divorce or separation, I can only imagine the extent of abnormal behaviors they may engage in to cope with the emotional distress. Do not judge yourself. Do what you have to do to survive. Eventually the dust will settle, you’ll find yourself amidst the chaos, and you’ll find your own path to healing. You can do this.

May 8, 2012

Is it getting kind of ovarian in here, or is it just my determination to remain childfree?

Has anyone else noticed that there have been a lot of articles in recently (like this afternoon) on this whole crazy idea that people (even women!) have complicated feelings about parenting? Here’s a sampling: 

What do we think is going on here? Is this just a notion being exoticized? (“Let’s go outside and look at the bears, and also the childfree women?”) Are people’s brains slowly creaking open to the idea that the childfree might not be selfish, evil, selfishly evil and pathological? What say you all? 

May 7, 2012

The Marriage Project, Reflection 50: “My life belongs to me now. It’s a beautiful thought.”

Thanks to everyone for being so patient and not rioting while the Marriage Project took a little break.I recently sent out a call to women who are divorced or separated and this is the first of those interviews.

L is 38 and lives in Central New York. 

Why did you decide to get married?

We’d been together six years, and though we’d had many problems, the relationship felt like an investment. I didn’t want to give up on it. Marriage was the next thing we were supposed to do, though, even at the time, I think we both had doubts. I’d been raised to believe that when you get married, you stay married, and I did believe this—for nearly a decade of marriage, I worked at and agonized over and rationalized issues that we’d had from the beginning that were essentially unsolvable because we were poorly matched for each other.

What changes have divorce/separation brought to your life?

I have one child, and being responsible for her mostly on my own is hard. But every day I feel relief that I’m not married anymore. Every day I feel thankful that I don’t have to live my life the way I was living it: feeling oppressed and controlled by another person, feeling devalued and criticized, feeling that any possibility of happiness was dependent on him. Now, even when I’m miserable, or I feel out of control because one of my jobs evaporates, or I’m momentarily lonely, or my daughter won’t eat anything I cook for her, I think: my life belongs to me now. It’s a beautiful thought.

How has divorce/separation changed your view of marriage?

I’ve learned that divorce is expensive, for one. And that sometimes, it’s necessary. I learned a lie from my mother that marriage is about self-sacrifice and making others happy even at the cost of your own happiness, and though my mother and I are both smart women, this has been a very hard lie to free ourselves of. This, instead, is my new truth: if a marriage (of mine) turns out to be horrible and miserable and unfixable, it’s the right thing (for me) to break it. I know some married couples who are happy and well-suited for each other, who have happy children, live in nice houses, etc. Or people who have some degree of those things. I think it’s possible to have those things and I’m happy for those people and a little sad that it didn’t work out for me that way—so far, anyway.

Do you think you’ll get married again? Why? Why not?

I don’t think I’ll ever get married again. I hope that someday (soon or not soon), I’ll be in a serious, marriage-like relationship, but the legal entanglements of marriage do not appeal to me, and in fact, they repel me, knowing how expensive it is to extricate myself from them. That said, you never know.

What advice would you give to women who are going through divorce/separation?

I did such a terrible job going through my separation/divorce. No one should do what I did: go crazy, lose too much weight, fall in love and get dumped, be angry and paranoid and depressed all the time, etc. I did one thing right, however: after the initial WTFness with my ex-husband wore off, we worked out a very amicable and generous visitation plan between him and our daughter (even though he does not have custody and behaved like a juicebox at the start of the separation). I think and hope this friendliness and time spent together helps her deal with the different-ness of her family.

May 7, 2012

“the things I have invented have invented me.” (dar williams)

I finally got a new camera, after watching the last one die a sudden death falling off a wall in Nicaragua after I’d owned it for two weeks. I get so obsessed with taking pictures, the camera starts to feel like a third hand after not very long.

IMG_0090

IMG_0091

 

red shoes

 

IMG_0096

April 29, 2012

16 and wearing “too much” nail polish and also pregnant.

 

 Fat and the Ivy’s awesome nails.

 

A few weeks ago at the CLPP conference, I went to a panel discussion called “Teen Families Take the Lead.” What attracted me to the panel was two fold-first, my well documented obsession with 16 and Pregnant and Teen Mom, and also the part of my brain that says that teen parenting will ruin your life, and the desire to be disproven. I tweeted the panel (#clpp2012), which featured Chelsea Kline, Ena Suseth Valladares, J’vaughnii Karakashian, Noalanii Karakashian, and Gretchen Sisson.

I came back to New York and watched numerous episodes of 16 and Pregnant and struggled to apply what I was now thinking to the show. Since not watching the show is apparently not an option, I’m going to write the following points on a Post-it and keep them within spitting distance:

* Why does being a young parent have to mean you ruined your life?
* There are advantages and disadvantages to having children at any all.
* People are one track minded about what parenthood should look like.
* If you believe in reproductive justice, you have to believe it’s for everyone.

And then I read some of the comments below the episodes, emailed Fat and the Ivy, and the following happened:

me: For the two hundredth time, while watching 16 and Pregnant, I noticed that in the comments, people had remarked on the fact that the girls have their nails done. They should be saving that money for the baby, etc, etc. It’s the same statement I’ve heard made in the Global South when I take participants there-people don’t have running water, but they have hair gel. For me, it’s about allowing people to be complicated and fully human and to do what they feel gives them dignity. We don’t get to decide how people spend their money, it’s another way in which we police bodies.

Fat and the Ivy: It’s also that nail polish can cost $1. We’re getting in such a huff over $1.  Yes, you can spend a lot more, but I have some fabulous colors with glitter and pizazz for under $5. It’s the downside of social welfare in capitalism.  Because we “earned” our money that gets redistributed through social welfare, we all feel entitled to police how “our” money is spent. There is a sense of entitlement and control that extends far beyond “paying ones dues” in society.  In this particular case is, we’re also dealing with misogyny. (What fun is capitalism without misogyny?!)  The comments speak to the ways in which the feminine is not valued.  Nail polish–a girly thing– is trivial and stupid.  It’s not worth time, energy, or money. And yet we still value women for their appearance. It’s such a completed fucked up system.

me: I was thinking that too. I don’t think these girls are getting manicures, but if they are? It’s STILL NONE OF OUR BUSINESS.  If you get pregnant at 16, you have to be punished to the fullest extent. Your life is over, and you deserve it. It’s the same conversation that gets had about weight and “health” and having to pay for other people’s health care. It makes me want to eat a sandwich and lay down. And then eat another sandwich, because you know, that’s what you do.

Fat and the Ivy: I see two things happening. The first is economic.  Our public welfare programs are in shambles and not able to support our basic dignities, and part of that is because we (as tax payers, as the landed classes) get to decide how other people spend “our money.” Of course, this is not an apolitical economic argument. If we really cared about “fiscal responsibility” birth control and abortions would be 100% covered and easily available. Plan B costs $40; a hospital birth costs thousands. 18 years of feeding, clothing, educating, and supporting a human being makes the abortion look like a better bargain than Groupon!

The second is the systematic devaluation of the feminine. We have this idea that what is feminine is unnatural– makeup, clothes, external things that you have to buy.  While we see the masculine as natural and innate– strength, facial hair, deep voices.  So when women engage in feminine things– like painting nails– we see it as something external, unnatural, and costly. And that means it’s and silly and wasteful.  It’s not artistic, enjoyable, relaxing, calming, or meaningful. And that means we, as a public, get to police it.

me: What’s also frustrating about reading the comments is that they are always from other young women, directed towards the young women on the show. I am aware of the alternative to not read the comments, but aside from morbid curiosity, I also feel like it’s important to read them because this is the stuff we have to fight against, and we should know about them.

I remember turning 20 and my friends and I saying to each other, WE ARE TOO OLD TO BE TEEN MOMS!!!!!! WAHOO!!!  It was more than the fact that we had dodged a (sperm?) bullet, it was that we thought we were actually better and smarter than these girls. We didn’t think about birth control being difficult to get and use, or about what makes it easier or harder to assert yourself or anything, other than that we were not stupid enough to get pregnant.

Fat and the Ivy: Fun fact: when I turned 20, I was a little bit disappointed that I wasn’t even going to be a teen mom, or even teen pregnant.  There goes my shot at being on MTV. But seriously, I think of this as a form of slut shaming. In high school, whenever someone got pregnant, the big deal wasn’t that she’s going to be a parent, but rather that she’s so slutty that she got knocked up. She’s having sex(!!) and she’s not even doing that right because she got preggers.

me: She doesn’t even feel badly about having sex!!!

Fat and the Ivy: THE HORROR!!!

me: Pregnancy is the punishment, it’s not just that she’s too dumb to use birth control, but it’s the punishment for being sexual and thinking that she’s entitled to pleasure. I always think during these episodes, I hope everyone involved had really good sex, and that they don’t regret it.

April 28, 2012

write about all the things.

people

(photo by me. Central Park, 2011)

Last Saturday, I drank sangria with Fat and the Ivy on the Lower East Side before we went to hear Dean Spade speak at Bluestockings. The whole night was pretty remarkable, which made up for the fact that I’d gotten out of my bed at 4 pm that day.

I’ve been feeling kind of haunted lately, at the same time as my political brain is surging forward and everything is becoming unraveled and simultaneously raveling into something else. I’m thinking mostly about the little voice that nags, that says things that I don’t actually believe. It’s important to remember that  it’s not that that voice is right, so much as well fed, rewarded, validated and consistent. At Dean Spade’s talk, he remarked on the fact that people seem to really believe that change on a certain scale, or towards a certain end, is impossible (i.e. the legal system, the corporate media, gender “norms,” capitalism.) To paraphrase Spade badly, of course the system is telling us it’s impossible, because within the system we’re operating in, it IS impossible. The point is to keep things the way they are so certain classes, races, etc., keep benefitting. The answer is to create new systems, which we can do and are doing. (See Wall Street, Occupy, etc.)

What I’m trying to do, perpetually, is to decolonize my brain. Last weekend, S and I went to a fancy brunch fundraiser for an abortion rights organization. (The tickets were free, as were the drinks, so I had two mimosas. WHO AM I?) One of the speakers who addressed the almost exclusively white, well coiffed crowd was a woman who told the story of  her abortion, which she had at 32 weeks upon learning that her very much wanted baby had a horrible, irreversible brain anomaly. She and her husband traveled to Colorado to have the abortion, and as she told us her story, she cried.

I just kept thinking that this is the story we have to tell to make abortion palatable to others-the government, each other.  If a woman is white and married and straight and has financial means and has other children, her abortion is acceptable. A woman who very much wants a child and has an abortion because of circumstances like the ones described, she will be asked to tell her story to move others. If that woman is of color, poor, young, not married, doesn’t want a child, etc., her abortion is unacceptable.

When I talk about  decolonizing my brain, I mean confronting thoughts like, well, just don’t have sex. See how that works? That trope, of who gets access to birth control, who should be able to have control over their reproductive capacity, who “deserves” sex, who deserves to have sex without getting pregnant, is alive in my head, it’s alive in all of our heads. The racism and classism and sexism. etc. has snuggled itself deeply into our brains after years of living in a world that rewards that shit. The task is to dig and unearth where it came from, and then it’s the shaking off of it. It’s sticky, though. It doesn’t come off easily. It’s scary to lose it, because then you have to figure out a whole new way to live and think. Keeping my brain in line with all those racist, sexist beliefs has not only kept me safe, it’s kept me buoyant.

It’s also kept me fucked up. Example: I am surrounded by folks who are really radical and smart and powerful. If we all combined our power and our energy and our brains, we could put a nice, big, quivering hole in the patriarchy. Instead, I find myself hesitant about sharing space, jealous at the accomplishments of other women, feeling badly about myself because I am not where they are. It was during a workshop at the CLPP conference that I had this revelation-the reason I feel this way has a lot to with capitalism. In capitalism, you don’t share. You get as much stuff as you can, because you deserve it, and you don’t give it away, and that includes credit for things you’ve done, made, etc. If you share, or redistribute, you lose what is YOURS. People who try to take away your stuff are doing so because they can’t get their own, and because they don’t deserve it. They didn’t work for it. They aren’t good enough, because clearly, the system hasn’t worked for them. (Remember that the premise is that the system is supposed to work for everyone, because it’s Fair.)

And in the meantime, the student loan debt in the United States has hit one trillion dollars, some of which is mine, and the existence of which is supposed to make us feel shitty and irresponsible and not good enough. That is another blog post all together. In the meantime, you’re probably tired. Take a day off.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.